top of page

Charles Ballay, M.D., Libertarian, Statement on Green Mass Transportation

Updated: Apr 8

In an age where high-speed and electric rail systems around the globe have become synonymous with economic prosperity, environmental sustainability, and enhanced connectivity, the United States' position on the sidelines of this transportation revolution is both conspicuous and concerning. This juxtaposition is particularly stark when set against the backdrop of nations like Japan, France, Germany, and China, whose investments in rail infrastructure reflect a harmonious blend of innovation, public policy, and private sector dynamism.

Japan's Shinkansen, or Bullet Train, offers a compelling case study of the transformative power of high-speed rail. Since its inauguration in 1964, the Shinkansen has revolutionized inter-city travel in Japan and contributed significantly to the nation's economic growth. It has carried over 10 billion passengers with an impeccable safety record, spurred economic development in regions connected by the network, and has been a key player in Japan's efforts to reduce its carbon footprint. The financial impact is profound; the Central Japan Railway Company reported annual revenues of approximately ¥1.7 trillion (about USD 15 billion) in 2019, illustrating the economic viability of high-speed rail systems.

Across the globe in France, the Train à Grande Vitesse (TGV) exemplifies high-speed rail's economic and environmental benefits. Since its launch in 1981, the TGV has become integral to France's national identity and financial infrastructure, connecting major cities and reducing travel times significantly. The TGV has carried over 2 billion passengers and has been instrumental in reducing road traffic and its associated emissions. Its success spurred infrastructure investments in secondary cities, demonstrating high-speed rail's role in balanced regional development.

Germany's focus on electrifying its rail network underscores the environmental imperatives driving the adoption of electric rail. The Deutsche Bahn (DB), Germany's national railway company, has committed to powering all its electric trains with 100% renewable energy by 2038, significantly reducing the transport sector's carbon emissions. This initiative positions Germany as a leader in sustainable transportation and highlights the potential for rail systems to contribute to national and global environmental goals.

Meanwhile, China's investment in the world's largest high-speed rail network has redefined the scope and scale of rail transport. Spanning over 37,000 kilometers, China's high-speed rail network has slashed travel times between major cities, bolstered economic integration, and become a pivotal element of the country's urbanization and development strategy. The network facilitated over 2 billion trips in 2019 alone, showcasing the massive demand for efficient and reliable public transport solutions.

Contrastingly, the United States' ventures into high-speed rail have been marred by setbacks and inefficiencies, exemplified by California's high-speed rail project. Initially estimated to cost $33 billion for a San Francisco to Los Angeles link, the project's budget has ballooned to over $80 billion, with completion dates pushed back by decades. This scenario starkly illustrates the challenges of government-led infrastructure projects, which often suffer from cost overruns, bureaucratic delays, and shifting political priorities.

The divergent outcomes between U.S. initiatives and international successes underline a crucial lesson: the private sector's agility, innovation, and efficiency can significantly mitigate the risks endemic to large-scale public infrastructure projects. While the U.S. pays homage to green energy and sustainable development ideals, the tangible commitment to realizing these goals through actionable infrastructure projects remains wanting. This discrepancy between rhetoric and action casts a shadow over the nation's ability to lead on the global stage regarding infrastructure innovation and environmental stewardship.

To align with global best practices and harness the full potential of high-speed and electric rail, the United States must pivot towards a model that emphasizes public-private partnerships, streamlined regulatory frameworks, and a clear, long-term vision for national infrastructure development. By drawing lessons particularly from European success with more private sector partnership, the U.S. can chart a course toward not only catching up with but potentially surpassing international standards in transportation infrastructure. This is a central element of infrastructure conspicuous in its absence if the United States is still a progressive global leader in ingenuity. The imperative to act is underscored by the competitive advantage and economic benefits at stake and the pressing need to address environmental challenges through sustainable development.

The future of U.S. transportation infrastructure hinges on a paradigm shift—a shift towards public-private partnerships embracing the efficiency, sustainability, and innovation demonstrated by high-speed and electric rail systems worldwide. The shift cannot be accomplished in the U.S. with a state-managed infrastructure. The time for the United States to reclaim its leadership role, innovate, and commit to a more connected, sustainable, and prosperous future is now. The global successes serve not just as a blueprint but a clarion call for action. The time for action is now; the future waits for no one.

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page